I Was One Way 2.0 T-Shirt

"I was one way, and now I’m completely different. And the thing that happened in between was Him.” - Mary Magdalene, Season 1, Episode Two

That simple truth is what makes Mary’s transformation so powerful…and warrants a second look.

We’ve partnered with illustrator Stephen Procopio to reimagine the “I Was One Way” Collection. Now, one of your favorite Chosen quotes is brought to life alongside the illustration of a dove in flight—the same dove that led Mary away from the edge of the cliff in Season 1.

Wear this tee as a reminder that Jesus changes everything for the better—leaving growth and freedom in His wake.

About the Artist

Stephen Procopio is an illustrator, husband, and father of three living in Northern Virginia. His work has been featured in churches and galleries across North America and Europe, even appearing in publications like Christianity Today and Lifeway Publishing. Stephen was hired to lend his talents to our show, and it’s amazing to watch him turn the bustling chaos of our set into something beautiful and contemplative.

Unisex Crewneck

Adult sizing
Side seamed
50/25/25 poly/Airlume combed and ring spun cotton/rayon
40 singles
3.8 oz.

Inspired by Season 1

You know the line:
“I was one way, and now I’m completely different. And the thing that happened in between… was Him.”

It’s more than a memorable quote; it's the moment everything changed for Mary Magdalene. In Season 1, Episode 2, her story shifts from shame to healing. The dove that appears before she meets Jesus? It’s not random. It’s a symbol of freedom. Of redemption. Of walking away from the edge and into something brand new.

That’s what inspired this 2.0 version of our best-selling “I Was One Way” tee. We partnered with illustrator Stephen Procopio to add a new layer of meaning to a fan favorite, featuring the familiar quote and a dove in mid-flight—or mid-transformation—just like Mary Magdalene.

Why Your Purchase Matters

You might be wondering why a show about Jesus has so many t-shirts. No, it’s not because tunics and leather sandals have gone out of style. It’s because we want as many people as possible to experience the story of Jesus—and we think they should hear about it from you.

So, thanks for sharing the show and purchasing something from our Gifts Store. You’re not just making the world a bit more teal. You’re inviting others to witness the story of Jesus—and maybe even experience transformation in the process.